Mostly summarized from Gregory Mankiw’s Principles of Economics, 5th Ed.
PART 6 The Economics of Labor Markets
Chapter 18 of 36 The Markets for the Factors of Production
Section 20 of 20
…
In this chapter we have seen how labor, land, and capital are paid for their roles in the production process.
The theory developed here is called the neoclassical theory of distribution.
According to this theory the amount paid to each factor of production depends on the supply and demand for that factor.
The demand depends on that factor's marginal productivity.
In equilibrium each factor of production earns the value of its marginal contribution to the production of goods and services.
…
Most economists begin with the neoclassical theory when trying to explain how the U.S. economy's $14 trillion of income is distributed among the economy's various members.
Why are computer programmers paid more than gas station attendants?
It’s because programmers produce more of a good of greater market value than gas station attendants.
People are willing to pay much for a good computer game, but they are only willing to pay a small amount to have their gas pumped and windshield washed.
The wages of these workers are determined by the quantity and market prices of the goods they produce.
If people suddenly tired of using computers and decided instead to spend more time driving the prices of these goods would change and so too would the equilibrium wages of these two groups of workers.
…
What is the communist theory take on the neoclassical theory of distribution?
ChatGPT:
From a communist or Marxist perspective, the neoclassical theory of distribution is viewed very critically.
Here’s the contrast:
Neoclassical View
Each factor of production (labor, capital, land) is paid its marginal product.
Distribution is seen as “fair” and based on productivity.
Wages reflect the value of labor’s contribution, profits reflect capital’s contribution, etc.
Communist / Marxist Take
Critique of “Fairness”
Marxists argue this theory hides the reality of exploitation.
Workers create the entire value of output, but capitalists appropriate a portion as profit.
The idea capital has its own “marginal product” is seen as a justification of inequality.
Labor Theory of Value vs. Marginal Productivity
Marx’s theory: value is created solely by labor.
Machines and capital are “frozen labor” (past labor embodied in tools).
Therefore, paying profits to capital owners is not rewarding productivity but transferring value created by workers.
Power, Not Markets
Communists argue income distribution reflects class power, not natural productivity.
Wages are kept below the full value of labor’s product through capitalist control of production.
Summary
Communists see the neoclassical theory of distribution as an ideological defense of capitalism, masking exploitation by claiming that each factor “earns what it contributes.”
Instead, they argue all value comes from labor, and profits are simply surplus value extracted from workers by capitalists.
…
If a worker feels he is being exploited by his employer why doesn’t he quit and find another employer who will pay him full value?
ChatGPT:
This question gets to the difference between the neoclassical view and the Marxist/communist critique.
Let’s unpack it:
Neoclassical (Mainstream Economics) Answer:
If a worker feels underpaid, in theory he can quit and move to another employer.
Competition among employers for workers drive wages up to equal the worker’s marginal product of labor (MPL).
In this view, exploitation shouldn’t persist in competitive markets — mobility and competition eliminate it.
Marxist / Communist Critique:
Structural Lack of Alternatives
Workers don’t own the means of production.
To survive, they must sell their labor to some capitalist.
Even if they quit one job, another employer still pays less than the full value of labor, because all employers operate under the same profit system.
Reserve Army of Labor
Marx argued unemployment (a “reserve army” of workers) keeps wages down.
With others willing to take the job, the worker has limited bargaining power.
Imperfect Competition and Power
Real-world labor markets are not perfectly competitive: unions are weak, information is imperfect, and mobility is limited - workers may not afford to move, retrain, or risk unemployment.
Employers often have monopsony-like (only one buyer of labor) power, especially in local labor markets.
Surplus Value Extraction
Even if wages rise, workers are still paid less than the full value they produce.
The difference (surplus value) goes to the capitalist as profit.
This is seen as structural exploitation, not just a wage dispute.
Summary
Neoclassical answer: Workers can and do leave if underpaid, competition ensures “fair” wages = productivity.
Communist answer: Workers cannot escape exploitation by changing jobs, because the system itself ensures they never receive the full value of what they produce — quitting just moves them from one exploiter to another.
…
Many say the problem is the worker thinks his value is higher than it is and is jealous of those who have higher value and are paid more, including owners/employers. Communism takes advantage of the resulting felt resentment of the worker by promising to "take from the rich and give to the poor."
ChatGPT:
You’re pointing to a psychological and political dimension of the worker–employer relationship that goes beyond just the technical economics.
Let’s unpack it:
The Worker’s Perception vs. Market Valuation
Neoclassical economics: Wages reflect marginal productivity — what a worker adds to output.
But many workers believe their value is higher than what the market pays. This can stem from:
Lack of visibility into what others contribute.
Comparing effort (“I work harder than the boss”) rather than market value.
Confusing absolute contribution with marginal contribution.
This mismatch creates a sense of resentment — not always because wages are objectively “unfair,” but because they feel unfair when compared to higher earners including executives, owners, professionals.
Jealousy and Resentment
Workers may resent the visible wealth of employers, especially when they themselves struggle.
The resentment is sharpened if employers seem to profit without “working as hard.”
This emotional factor helps explain why some workers don’t see “just quit and find another job” as a sufficient answer.
How Communism Leverages This
Communist ideology frames this resentment as evidence of systemic injustice.
The narrative: “You are exploited because the rich are taking more than their fair share.”
The political promise: redistribution (“take from the rich and give to the poor”) and an end to “exploitation” through collective ownership.
This is why communist movements historically gained traction in times of sharp inequality, unemployment, or social unrest — moments when worker resentment was widespread.
Balanced View
From a mainstream economics lens: resentment may partly be a perception problem — workers overestimating their contribution relative to others.
From a Marxist/communist lens: resentment is a structural reality — the worker is exploited, because profit necessarily comes from surplus value taken from labor.
Either way, resentment creates a fertile ground for ideologies that promise radical change.
Summary:
Many workers feel underpaid not only because of actual wages, but because they perceive an unfair gap between themselves and owners/employers.
Communism capitalizes on this feeling by presenting inequality as systemic exploitation, promising to redistribute wealth and power.
(End of chapter 18 of 36)
…
Congratulations! 50%, 18 of 36 chapters, of way to becoming competent economist.


Comments
Post a Comment