From Great State: China and the World. Timothy Brook. 2020. Kindle online sample. Section 1.
From introduction:
Timothy Brook analyzes THE LAST EIGHT CENTURIES OF CHINA’S RELATIONSHIP WITH THE WORLD in this magnificent history that brings together accounts from civil servants, horse traders, spiritual leaders, explorers, pirates, emperors, migrant workers, invaders, visionaries, and traitors—creating a multifaceted portrait of this highly misunderstood nation.
…
It ACHIEVED ITS APPROXIMATE CURRENT BORDERS WITH THE ASCENDANCY OF THE YUAN DYNASTY IN THE THIRTEENTH CENTURY, and despite the passing of one Imperial dynasty to the next, has maintained them for the eight centuries since.
China remained China through the Ming, the Qing, the Republic, Japan’s Occupation, and Communism.
…
Despite the desires of some of the most powerful people in the Great State through the ages, China has never been alone in the world.
It has had to contend with invaders as well as foreign traders and imperialists.
ITS RULERS FOR THE MAJORITY OF THE LAST EIGHT CENTURIES HAVE NOT BEEN CHINESE.
…
China became a mega-state not by conquering others, but rather by being conquered by others and then claiming right of succession to the empires of those Great States.
What the Mongols and Manchu ruling families wrought, the Chinese ruling families of the Ming, the Republic, and the People’s Republic, have perpetuated.
Yet a contemporary Chinese idea of a ‘fatherland’ that is, and always has been, completely and naturally Chinese persists.
Brook argues China, like everywhere, is the outcome of history, and LIKE EVERY STATE, RESTS ON ITS CAPACITIES TO CONQUER AND SUPPRESS.
…
In The Great State, Brook examines China’s relationship with the world at large for the first time, from the Yuan through to the present, by FOLLOWING THE STORIES OF ORDINARY AND EXTRAORDINARY PEOPLE navigating the spaces where China met, and continues to meet, the world.
….
From book sample:
What I have written in this book is not a ponderous tome that slogs through eight centuries of Chinese history dynasty by dynasty—or, at least, I hope that’s not what is on offer.
Rather, I have tried to craft an account for general readers of HOW CHINA HAS BEEN IN THE WORLD SINCE THE THIRTEENTH CENTURY and what that has meant for the world and for China.
…
I have organized the book not as an elucidation of grand themes but as A SERIES OF THIRTEEN MOMENTS ACROSS SEVEN CENTURIES THAT REFLECT SIGNIFICANT FACETS, to me at least, of the historical relationships between China and the world.
…
I want to give readers a chance to see what has happened in particular, concrete situations, before asking you to think about China’s relationships with the world today.
Two basic ideas drive this book.
One is the recognition CHINA HAS NEVER NOT BEEN PART OF THE WORLD, either in the past or in our own day.
We have no way to understand China if we separate it from the world.
…
The other is the fundamental principles guiding the Chinese state today were established
-not in the late third century BCE, which is where Chinese history usually goes to discover its emergence as a unified state in a long string of dynasties
-but IN THE THIRTEENTH CENTURY CE, WHEN CHINA WAS ABSORBED INTO THE MONGOL WORLD
…
The Mongol occupation had a profound impact, shifting China from the older dynastic model to a form that, following Mongol usage, I call the Great State.
Without this concept we are without a key tool needed to understand China from the perspective of history.
THE IDEA CHINA HAS ALWAYS BEEN ENTANGLED IN THE WORLD IS ONE THAT HISTORIANS OF CHINA NOW GENERALLY RECOGNIZE.
In taking this approach, I write simply as part of my generation.
…
Here in the twenty-first century, two bridges between China and the world remain still to be built.
One is the bridge between the China of history and the China of now.
The other is between China today and a world that has become increasingly troubled by its expansive presence.
THIS BOOK IS DEDICATED TO WORKING ON THAT FIRST BRIDGE IN THE HOPE THAT, BY ENCOUNTERING CHINA AS IT WAS, WE MIGHT BE IN A BETTER POSITION TO SEE CHINA AS IT IS.
…
A few years ago, an enterprising graduate student at the University of British Columbia (UBC), where I work, was poking about in the geography section of the Asian Library.
There, folded neatly inside a twentieth-century pasteboard slipcase, he found a Chinese wall map from the Ming dynasty (1368–1644).
When unfolded, the map was impressively large, four feet wide and four and a half from top to bottom (see Plate 1) [not shown in book sample perhaps at back of book, no name for map given, believe the attached found in Google Images].
…
We can’t say that the map was lost.
It had a call number on the spine and an incomplete entry in the library catalogue, and it sat there in the open stacks for anyone to pick it up.
It’s just that no one had.
In its day it was an ordinary object.
You could have bought it for the price of a wok, or maybe 2 pounds of high-grade Philippine tobacco.
Today it would fetch a shocking price, which is why, when the student showed it to the librarian, she removed it from the open stacks and locked it in the rare books room.
…
The map has the classic look of a Ming dynasty production.
It molds China into a rectangular shape, on the premise that Heaven may be round but the earth is square, and it sequesters the country within the bounds of the Great Wall along its northern border.
But what is it a map of, really?
We look at it and see a map of China, WHEREAS PEOPLE OF THE MING WOULD HAVE REGARDED IT DIFFERENTLY, AS A MAP NOT OF CHINA BUT OF THE WORLD.
…
Their term for such a map was hua-yi tu, “a map of Chinese (hua) and non-Chinese (yi),” or barbarians, to give the latter its due resonance.
Cartouches in the ocean describe foreign places from Korea and Japan to Brunei and Malacca, and text boxes in the wastes beyond the Great Wall explain who the Khitans, Jurchens, Mongols, Turks, and Tibetans are.
FOUR CENTURIES AGO THIS WAS WHAT PASSED FOR A MAP OF THE WORLD OR, MORE PRECISELY, A MAP OF CHINA IN THE WORLD.
…
The more I examined this map, though, the more mysterious and elusive it became.
The publisher’s colophon in the bottom left-hand corner declares that it was printed in Nanjing, the secondary capital of the Ming dynasty and a major publishing center, by Ji Mingtai [Master Ji of the Terrace of Renown] in the year guiwei.
CHINESE YEARS ARE NAMED ACCORDING TO A SIXTY-YEAR CYCLE, and normally the year name is prefixed with the reign title of the emperor on the throne at the time to distinguish one guiwei year from the next.
The design of the map reminded me of a visually very similar map I had seen published in the same city bearing the date of 1593, so I reasoned that guiwei was either the guiwei year of the Wanli reign, 1583, or the guiwei year of the Chongzhen reign sixty years later, 1643.
…
Eventually I tracked down a copy in the Harvard-Yenching Library at Harvard University on which the date was printed in full: Chongzhen guiwei.
THAT CONFIRMED THE DATE: 1643.
The 1593 map I had in mind as a precursor to the one in Vancouver was another large wall map, this one drawn by a schoolteacher named Liang Zhou.
It surfaced at a Sotheby’s auction in 1988 only to disappear immediately into another private collection, yet it was in the public realm long enough to be photographed and to circulate among scholars.
…
What for me clinched the relationship between these two maps was that they carried the SAME SUBTITLE: “WITH HUMAN VESTIGES AND RECORDS OF EVENTS ANCIENT AND MODERN.”
This stilted phrasing, which sounds more like advertising copy than truthful description, betrays the fact that they must share an origin, or at least a mutual influence.
Their main titles are different, however.
The map in Vancouver is called The Terrestrial Map of the Astral Correspondences of the Nine Provinces.
The references to “nine provinces” and “astral correspondences” look back into the past by summoning up ancient conceptions of Chinese geography.
…
The 1593 map bears a different title, The Complete Map of the Ten Thousand Countries Between Heaven and Earth.
Unlike the 1643 map, the 1593 title declares the map to be a map of the world, which is striking, given the ON-AGAIN, OFF-AGAIN MING BAN ON CONTACT WITH THE WORLD BEYOND CHINA’S BORDERS.
…
These may not look to us like maps of the world, but they have absorbed no small amount of foreign knowledge.
The best sign of this on the 1593 map is the debut appearance of the Arctic Ocean complete with North Pole, details that Ji Mingtai regrettably dropped when he drew his version.
In the text printed across the top of his map Liang Zhou reveals his source for the new content to be a six-panel map of the world that had been recently engraved in Nanjing on slabs of stone so that anyone could consult it.
“For the first time,” Liang proclaims, there is a map that “allows you to understand to the most precise degree how Heaven and Earth are contained.”
(end of section 1)
… …

Comments
Post a Comment