From A Brief History of the Cold War. John Hughes. 2019. Kindle online sample. Section 3.
After they had consolidated their successful revolution, THE BOLSHEVIKS’ [COMMUNISTS’] FOREIGN POLICY WAS SHAPED BY THREE MAIN FACTORS.
1- The inheritance of the historic Czarist-Russian expansionism from the previous century – the Bolsheviks had effectively put the old Russian Empire ‘under new management’.
2- Lenin’s ruling circle held deeply embedded ideological notions that a fundamental clash between Marxism and capitalism was inevitable.
3- The new Russian leaders simply had to survive in a sea of enemies.
…
NOBODY IN THE EARLY 1920S EXPECTED THEM TO SURVIVE, even the Bolsheviks themselves, assailed as they were on every side by enemies within and without.
From their stolen battlements in the Kremlin, Lenin and his heirs looked out on a dangerous world.
Overshadowing this whole view from the new Russia of the 1920s was the bitter memory of western intervention on the side of their Czarist enemies during Russia’s civil war from 1919 to 1922.
…
This early struggle for continued existence by the hard-nosed clique around Lenin crystallized into a continuing world view of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics which placed it implacably at odds with the western powers.
Like some zealous counter-reformation bishop, LENIN BELIEVED HE WAS FULLY AUTHORIZED BY HIS OWN SECULAR FAITH – MARXISM – TO USE ANY MEANS POSSIBLE TO BRING ABOUT A SOCIALIST UTOPIA.
…
From such fanaticism naturally flowed a suspicion of anyone who disagreed with him and confrontation with his bourgeois neighbors.
Given the Bolsheviks’ pathological suspicion of the liberal values espoused by Woodrow Wilson’s ‘Fourteen Points’ at the Versailles Peace Conference of 1919, it now seems obvious to us dangerous ideas like INDIVIDUAL FREEDOM, FREE TRADE, OPEN MARKETS AND SELF-DETERMINATION WERE THE LAST THINGS LENIN AND HIS PARTY WANTED TO SEE, let alone tolerate, inside the new Russia.
…
Marxist communism meant planning, planning meant control, control meant ordering people to do what the Party ordered.
Failure to obey the Party had to be punished.
THE TWISTED LOGIC OF MARXISM ENSURED THE RISE OF A POLICE STATE FAR HARSHER THAN ANY CZAR’S: at least until the state ‘withered away’.
In the Marxist paradise of revolutionary Russia, the state showed little sign of withering away.
…
In fact, THE ‘DICTATORSHIP OF THE PROLETARIAT’ HAD TURNED OUT TO BE THE DICTATORSHIP OF THE BOLSHEVIKS and their Communist Party.
It seemed to ensure proper social control brutal repression was the order of the day.
It was all very confusing for revolutionary Marxists.
The Red tyranny of Lenin and the Bolsheviks was to prove Bakunin’s chilling prophecy of 1870 only too accurate: ‘Take the most radical revolutionary and place him on the throne of Russia with dictatorial power and within a year he will be a greater tyrant than the Czar.’
…
The irony was that for many in the west, socialism, Russian style, seemed to offer real hope.
A generation worn out by the upheavals and losses of 1914–18 and constant social strife looked approvingly to the ‘new Russia’.
Here was the answer to the ills of capitalism with all its inequalities and problems?
THE BOLSHEVIK RULERS OF RUSSIA TURNED GRATEFULLY TO THESE NEW FRIENDS IN THE WEST, WHOM LENIN CALLED ‘HELPFUL IDIOTS,’ FOR BOTH SUPPORT AND HELP.
They willingly obliged.
…
The result was from the mid-1920s onwards the Kremlin was able to mount a sophisticated campaign to take over and control many of the ‘progressive organs’ in the west.
The Kremlin recognized the ideological nature of the struggle between capitalism and communism long before the west had woken up to the reality of the threat.
For the hard-nosed and committed early Cold War warriors of the USSR, THE LEFT IN THE WEST WAS A VERY SOFT TARGET FOR COMMUNIST RUSSIA’S MESSAGE.
…
Foremost in the vanguard of seekers after this ‘new truth’ were, surprisingly, many western intellectuals.
While ill-informed down-trodden workers and their semi-communist trade union leaders in the west could be forgiven for supposing Stalin’s USSR offered a genuine model of a workers’ paradise, THE SO-CALLED INTELLECTUALS AND ACADEMICS WHO VISITED THE SOVIET UNION, UNDER CAREFULLY CONTROLLED SECRET POLICE GUIDANCE, HAD NO EXCUSE FOR THEIR SUPPORT.
…
Blindly, a generation of starry-eyed thinkers like H. G. Wells and Beatrice and Sidney Webb, the founders of the left-wing Fabian Society, [and Robert Oppenheimer, later to become a leader of the Manhattan Project] WERE EITHER DUPED, EXCUSED, OR REFUSED TO ACKNOWLEDGE THE BRUTAL EXCESSES OF STALIN, LENIN’S HEIR.
Somehow the great intellects of the left seemed to be able to overlook the blatant bureaucratic terrorism, the slaughter of the better-off peasants and the deliberate engineering of famine in the Ukraine, in order to better eulogize their own vision of some new Jerusalem of socialist joy.
The result was in the late 1920s and early 1930s the brutal excesses Stalin perpetrated in forging his totalitarian dictatorship found western apologists only too easily.
…
In 1926 the Soviet Trade Unions offered millions of pounds to support Britain’s coalminers, who were heavily involved in the General Strike.
This obvious interference in Britain’s internal affairs caused outrage.
The British Security Service (MI5) had PLENTY OF CLEAR EVIDENCE THE BOLSHEVIKS’ REPRESENTATIVES IN LONDON WERE BLATANTLY ENGAGED IN SUBVERSION AND SPYING.
The subsequent police raid on the Russians’ trade mission in May 1927 further embittered relations between Moscow and London, and on 26 May 1927 Britain broke off all diplomatic ties with the Kremlin.
Although the new Labour government restored them in 1929, from the mid-1920s onwards Whitehall regarded Moscow as a dangerous and destabilizing menace.
…
American opposition to Russia’s communist regime was even more clear-cut.
From the very start, AMERICANS HAD CONSIDERED THE BOLSHEVIST USSR AS LITTLE MORE THAN AN ANTI-DEMOCRATIC REVOLUTIONARY OLIGARCHY HOLDING DOWN THE RUSSIAN PEOPLE BY FORCE, and by force alone.
This clear-thinking recognition of a harsh reality – while uncomfortable to old-style diplomats accustomed to presenting the international world in delicate shades of grey – was backed by a hard-headed conviction Soviet-style socialism was totally incompatible with American ideals of a free market economy.
…
Lenin’s own rhetoric did little to help.
In 1918 he had addressed a call to arms to American workers, in which he called their President, Woodrow Wilson, the ‘chief of the American multi-millionaires and the lackey-slave of the capitalist sharks’.
Such language was hardly calculated to foster international cordiality. Unsurprisingly, THE USA FLATLY REFUSED TO RECOGNIZE THE USSR IN THE 1920s AS ANYTHING OTHER THAN AN ABERRATION AND A PARIAH STATE.
Even the new Soviet ambassador to Mexico was banned from travelling across American soil to take up her new job.
…
THE AMERICAN PRESS SUPPORTED THIS HARD OFFICIAL ANTI-SOVIET LINE, OPENLY OPPOSING THE USSR and broadcasting its failures.
Headlines such as “Famine strikes Russia, hundreds die in Ukraine riots and Soviet Party in chaos as trade, industry totter” could hardly improve relations with the Bolsheviks’ regime, especially as they were so very obviously true.
The USA’s awareness of communist and Bolshevik subversion in the 1920s was only too accurate, however much it made European socialists wince.
…
RUSSIAN AGENTS IN THE USA TRIED TO SUBVERT THE WEAK US LABOR UNIONS IN A DETERMINED EFFORT TO UNDERMINE AMERICAN CAPITALISM.
This clash placed the USA implacably in the battle-lines of the Soviet Union’s enemies from the start, and both sides knew it.
For Russia and for the USA the struggle was ideological from the beginning.
…
It was against this backdrop of subversion, distrust and diplomatic conflict that a single major event changed virtually everything.
IN 1929, THE WALL STREET STOCK MARKET COLLAPSED AND THE WORLD’S ECONOMIC SYSTEM COLLAPSED WITH IT.
As demand fell, unemployment soared and ‘free capitalism’ stood discredited.
The impoverishment of the bourgeoisie went hand in glove with falling share prices and bankrupt bankers begging in Wall Street.
…
SOCIALISTS EVERYWHERE HAILED THE VINDICATION OF MARXISM, as its great ideological enemy appeared to be on the verge of a final meltdown.
Banks were going bust, millions were ruined, soup kitchens fed thousands in New York.
Marx had been right all along.
A glorious new socialist world order beckoned from the ruins of the old. Capitalism and democracy had been shown to be failures.
Socialism was the hope of the future.
…
The great liberal democracies of the west reacted in different ways to this threat to their economic and social stability.
While Britain and France tried desperately to cope with the Great Depression by Parliamentary methods, German democracy voted as Chancellor a new Bismarck to act as their strong leader in a time of trouble - Adolf Hitler.
Hitler was to prove somewhat stronger than many of his German voters had bargained for. ‘
DEMOCRACY IS THE SOURCE OF GERMANY’S TROUBLES,’ HITLER BAWLED IN A HUNDRED SPEECHES, along with steady rants about the Versailles ‘Diktat’, the lack of work and discipline, the Jews and, above all, too much political confusion in postwar Germany.
…
‘Just how many political parties does a working state really need?’ he asked.
One of his first acts, after having swiftly established himself as dictator of a one-party state, was therefore to lock up all the Communists and their socialist camp followers.
Mussolini of Italy looked admiringly on.
For many, as trade dried up and millions became unemployed, FASCISM SEEMED TO OFFER A VIABLE A SOLUTION TO THE ILLS OF THE WEST .
…
America’s response to the Great Depression was to introduce ‘Government’ money as a new source of capital to revive a stricken economy, to the outrage of many of the great magnates of capitalism.
But in a dark decade, where the song ‘Buddy, Can You Spare Me a Dime?’ reflected the hopelessness of mass unemployment, UNFETTERED CAPITALISM SEEMED TO HAVE LITTLE MORE TO OFFER FOR MOST FOLK.
…
As part of his ‘New Deal’, America’s new President, Franklin Delano Roosevelt, also reconsidered the USA’s position on Soviet Russia, and IN 1933 THE USA RECOGNIZED THE USSR.
One of the very first American diplomats to be sent to Moscow was a young State Department officer, George F. Kennan, a man who was to have a long influence on American perceptions of the Cold War.
From his new Moscow office, Kennan soon realized the ideological chasm between east and west was gaping wide and was effectively unbridgeable.
He warned Washington ‘There can be no possible middle ground or compromise between the two systems.”
…
Kennan reported the Soviet Union was totally opposed to the west’s traditions, values and political systems.
The more he observed of Russian communism at first hand, the more Kennan realized THE ENMITY BETWEEN CAPITALIST WEST AND THE COMMUNIST EAST WAS IMPLACABLE AND IDEOLOGICAL AT ITS CORE and must inevitably lead to conflict.
…
Events like the 1933 show trial of six British Metropolitan Vickers engineers working on a Soviet building contract did little to ease the tense climate of suspicion surrounding Anglo-Soviet relations.
ALL WESTERNERS WERE POTENTIAL SPIES AND COUNTER-REVOLUTIONARY TO STALIN’S RUSSIA.
However, Kennan’s perceptive analysis of the true nature of the ideological conflict underpinning all relations with Stalin’s USSR found little favor in the Great Depression of the mid-1930s.
…
To many in the west, Russia instead appeared more than ever a beacon of hope in a collapsing, discredited world.
There seemed to be no hunger in the planned socialist economy of the USSR and everyone had a job.
Industry was booming under the Party’s ‘Five Year Plan.’
SOVIET PROPAGANDA CINEMA SHOWED CHEERFUL PEASANTS GATHERING YET ANOTHER BUMPER HARVEST UNDER SUNLIT SKIES as burly men toiled over hot steel in modern industrial foundries to meet the Party’s norms.
…
To the unemployed and hungry of the west, the Soviet Union often seemed a genuine workers’ paradise, Communism worked.
You only had to look at the newsreels.
Beneath the surface of this new diplomatic and ideological rapprochement, however, an ugly new phenomenon began to take root.
Nations have always spied on each other.
But in the 1930s, STALIN’S INTELLIGENCE SERVICES BEGAN A NEW AND DEADLY ASSAULT ON AN UNPRECEDENTED SCALE TO SPY ON THOSE THEY PERCEIVED AS THEIR FOREIGN ENEMIES.
From the start mainly Britain and America were on the receiving end of this secret intelligence war.
(end of section 3)
… …
(own comments)
Section 1
“The Cold War did not only deform lives, it deformed whole societies, as well as costing a fortune.”
Substantially lowering taxes and allowing imports to freely come into the U.S., as with among U.S. states, would enrich Americans so much other countries would soon follow our model.
THAT Libertarian Real Republican dominance would force less federal dependence and power and more state independence and power.
THAT independence would induce All countries to follow and join in the U.S.A.-led All countries reformation into the U.S. of World.
Since All countries would be like post-HATrs’ turn round squares reformed U.S. states there would be no more felt need to spend a fortune on militaries.
Certainty having defeated doubt, general interests having defeated special interests, instability of justice having defeated stability of injustice, positive happy having defeated negative misery, with reformed lives and societies We’ll All go together to becoming in-there millionaires and billionaires, and will have plenty of money to spread tHAT verse throughout universe.
(Byrds song Wild Mountain Thyme)
…
Section 2
“The Russian Communists’ war against the bourgeoisie and the rest of the world really began on that first day of their revolution.”
“It was the Cheka secret police who set up the first camps of what became known as the Gulag on Solovetsky Island as early as 1922.
The Russian revolution was consummated by communists in name only, but rather actually by the 5% shapeless-form mafia and supporting 47.5% negative misery-wuvvers (we’re united victims and victimizers).
The 47.5% positive happy-lovers are the third of three sections present in all populations of Russia, U.S. and all countries, past, present, and future.
When the positives dominate happy increases, when the negatives dominate misery increases.
….
Section 3
“Lenin believed he was fully authorized by his own secular faith – Marxism – to use any means possible to bring about a socialist Utopia. Individual freedom, free trade, open markets and self-determination were the last things Lenin and his Party wanted to see.”
“The left in the west was a very soft target for communist Russia’s message.”
As increasing leftism/socialism in U.S. and western countries weakens, Xi-China strengthens.
Then Communism actual goal of worldwide total misery-wuv dystopia under control of zeir Xi-politburo to become reality, welcomed by half of people here and everywhere.
Comments
Post a Comment